* Look for our favorites!

* Haystack Onion Rings  $6.99  /  Half order - $5.99
Nisleit’s thinly sliced onion rings are lightly breaded and fried right here in our kitchen

Triple Cheese Chicken Quesadillas  $8.99  /  Without chicken $7.99
Three cheese, pepper jack, cheddar and provolone, served with sour cream and salsa

Chicken Wings $7.79
Eight meaty, fried wings coated in your choice  of  BBQ, Teriyaki, Sriracha, garlic butter or buffalo. Bone in or Boneless.

Nisleit’s Own Mozzarella Marinara  $6.99
Six mozzarella cheese sticks tossed in our homemade bread crumb blend and served golden brown with our homemade marinara

Wisconsin Cheddar Cheese Nuggets  $6.49
Lightly breaded and deep fried natural cheddar cheese

Potato Skins  $6.99
Five potato skins loaded with bacon, cheddar jack cheese and green onions.  Served with sour cream

Nisleit's Combo Platter $9.99
Haystack onion rings, breaded cauliflower and mushrooms served with ranch dressing

Cheese Lover Combo $10.99
Three mozzarella cheese sticks, cheddar cheese nuggets, and haystack onion rings.

Fried Pickles $5.99 / Half Order $3.99
Eight Kosher Dill pickle spears dippeed in our special batter. Served golden brown with ranch dressing.


Soup of the day  Bowl - $3.99  /  Cup - $2.99

* Nisleit’s Famous Baked French Onion Soup  Bowl - $4.99  /  Cup - $3.99


* Cashew Chicken Salad $10.99
Cashew nuts sprinkled over mixed greens with shredded cheddar cheese, sliced mushrooms, black olives, cucumbers and tomatoes.  Topped with grilled sliced chicken breast and red onions and toasted sesame dressing served on the side

Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad  $9.49  /  Without chicken - $7.79
Fresh grilled chicken breast on top of crisp romaine lettuce tossed with our own Caesar dressing, parmesan cheese and homemade croutons

Taco Salad  $9.99
A crispy tortilla shell filled with lettuce, seasoned ground beef, shredded cheese, tomatoes, black olives and green onions served with salsa and sour cream

Hot Bacon Salad  $9.99
Fresh grilled chicken breast sliced and sautéed with scallions in our hot bacon dressing over fresh spinach and garden greens

Chef’s Salad  $9.49
Julienne ham, turkey, Swiss and cheddar cheeses on top of fresh garden greens with your choice of dressing

Apple Walnut Chicken Salad $10.99
Grilled marinated chicken breast on top of fresh mixed greens, crisp sliced apples, crumbled bleu cheese, and sweet candied walnuts, tossed in our tasty balsamic vinaigrette dressing.


All Served with Freshly Baked Bread.
Add a Cup of Soup or a House Salad for only $0.99

Open Faced Steak Sandwich $14.99
A 6 oz. beef tenderloin steak on toast.  Served with your choice of potato

Broiled Tilapia $9.99
A 6 oz. sweet and flaky fillet broiled to perfection served with your choice of potato

Chicken Tenders  $9.99
Meaty, batter dipped sliced chicken breasts served golden brown with French fries and ranch dressing

Lake Perch Plate $14.99
Hand-breaded fresh late perch served with creamy homemade coleslaw, rye bread and choice of potato.

Hand-Breaded Butterfly Gulf Shrimp  $10.99
Four lightly hand-breaded shrimp served golden brown with tangy cocktail sauce and your choice of potato

*  Broasted Chicken  $9.49
Two pieces of crispy chicken served with your choice of potato

Smothered Chicken Breast  $11.99
Chicken breast grilled with sautéed mushrooms, green peppers and onions, topped with Monterey jack and cheddar cheeses. Served over garlic mashed potatoes and seasonal vegetables

Smothered Steak $12.99
Tender grilled steak with sauteed mushrooms, green peppers and onions. Topped with Monterey jack and cheddar cheeses. Served over garlic mashed potatoes and seasonal vegetables

Pan- Fried Beef Liver $11.99  / One Piece $10.49
Two 4 oz. pieces of pan-fried baby beef liver smothered with fried onions and topped with bacon.  Served with your choice of potato.

Chicken Alfredo $12.49
Grilled chicken strips in a creamy Alfredo sauce served over penne pasta.
Blackened $12.99

New! Hot Beef Sandwich $10.99
Thinly sliced roast beef served hot, on top of white bread with mashed potatoes and smothered in gravy.


House Salad $2.49
French Fries, Baked Potato or Hash Browns $1.99
Sautéed Whole Mushrooms $4.49
Sautéed Sliced Mushrooms $1.99
Seasonal Vegetables $1.99
Bleu Cheese Crumbles $0.99
Baked French Onion Soup Substitute $0.99
Cottage Cheese, Apple sauce or Cole Slaw $1.49
Homemade Potato Pancakes Substitute $1.49
Hand-Breaded Butterfly Shrimp $1.99/piece

Served with cup of homemade soup or garden salad, and fresh bread
*Nisleit’s Favorites

BBQ Baby Back Ribs  Full rack - $21.99  /  Half rack - $18.99
Meaty ribs glazed with tangy BBQ sauce and served with your choice of potato and seasonal vegetables.

* Prime Rib
12 oz. Downtown Cut - $19.99
16 oz. City Cut - $22.99
24 oz. Country Cut - $27.99
48 oz. Land Lover Cut - $49.99
Slow roasted and served every day of the week. Served with your choice of potato, seasonal vegetables and au jus

Cheese or Beef Ravioli  $14.99
Your  choice of ricotta cheese filled or seasoned ground beef served with marinara sauce and parmesan cheese

Broasted Chicken $11.99
Four pieces of crispy chicken, served with your choice of potato and seasonal vegetables

Grilled Boneless Pork Chops  Two chops - $16.45  /  One chop - $12.45
6 oz. center cut chops served with homemade applesauce, your choice of potato and seasonal vegetables.

New! Homemade Meatloaf $10.99
Blend of beef and pork mixed with all the right ingredients. Served with your choice of potato and seasonal vegetables.

Tenderloin Tips  $16.49
Sautéed beef tips topped with tomatoes, green peppers, onions and mushrooms.  Served over your choice of garlic mashed potatoes, penne pasta or wild rice.

Chopped Sirloin Steak  $13.99
Freshly ground-in-house sirloin, grilled to your liking and topped with mushroom sauce. Served with your choice of potato and seasonal vegetables.

*Chicken Cordon Bleu $15.99
Boneless chicken breast stuffed with smoked ham and creamy Swiss cheese, baked to perfection and topped with hollandaise sauce. Served over wild rice with seasonal vegatables.

Chicken Parmigiana  $15.99
Boneless chicken breast lightly breaded and pan-fried, topped with melted mozzarella and marinara sauce. Served on a bed of penne pasta

Chicken Marsala $15.99
Three 3 oz. boneless chicken breasts sauteed in butter, smothered in a Marsala wine and mushroom sauce. Served on a bed of wild rice with seasonal vegetables.

* Rib Eye  $22.99
A 12 oz. hand cut steak grilled to perfection and topped with our homemade haystack onion rings. Served with your choice of potato and seasonal vegetables.

Butterfly Gulf Shrimp  $18.49
Seven large hand breaded shrimp, served golden brown. Served with your choice of potato and seasonal vegetables.

Broiled Talapia  $14.99
Two, 6 oz. filets broiled and, served with tartar sauce, lemon, choice of potato and seasonal vegetables.

Fresh Canadian Walleye  $17.99
Your choice of pan fried or broiled, then topped with toasted almonds.  Served with your choice of potato and seasonal vegetables.

New! Grilled Salmon $16.99
An 8 oz. filet grilled and smothered with homemade creamy dill sauce. Served with your choice of potato and seasonal vegetables.

Served with your choice of French fries or cup of soup or sweet potato fries (.99 extra)

Cup and a Half $6.45
A cup of homemade soup and your choice of one these sandwiches: Grilled Cheese & Ham, BLT, Tuna or Chicken Salad Melt or Grilled Turkey & Cheese.

* Philly Cheese Steak  $10.49
Tender, sliced and seasoned rib eye, topped with sautéed green peppers, onions and melted mozzarella cheese.

Hamburger  $8.99
A One-half pound fresh ground beef patty.
Add your choice of cheese  $0.75

Bacon Cheeseburger $10.29
A One-half pound fresh ground beef patty topped with hickory smoked bacon and your choice of cheese.

Patty Melt  $9.49
A seasoned beef patty topped with grilled onions, Swiss cheese and 1000 island dressing.

Reuben  $9.49
Sliced tangy corned beef topped with sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and 1000 island dressing on grilled rye bread.

New! Pulled BBQ Pork $8.99
Slow roasted pulled pork in our tangy BBQ sauce.

 Prime Rib Sandwich  $15.99
Slow roasted, thinly sliced prime rib served on a hoagie with Au jus.

Steak Sandwich  $11.99
6 oz. tenderloin grilled to your liking.
Add sautéed onions and mushrooms for $1.00

Chicken Breast  $9.49
A grilled chicken breast seasoned the way you like it, with lemon pepper or Cajun, or just plain.  Served with lettuce and tomato.

Tuna or Chicken Salad Melt  $8.99
Your choice of homemade salad on grilled wheat bread with melted cheddar cheese.

Perch Sandwich  $10.99
hand breaded flaky perch served golden brown with tartar sauce and lemon.

Classic Triple-Decker Club  $9.99
Layers of turkey, ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and bacon on your choice of toast.

Ranch Chicken Wrap  $9.49
Grilled chicken breast served with parmesan cheese, tomatoes, red onion and loaded with lettuce all wrapped up in a flour tortilla.

Prime Rib Wrap $10.99
Slices of prime rib, fried onions, mushrooms, shredded cheese all wrapped in a large tortilla shell.

Haystack Burger $10.79
A 1/2 lb. fresh ground beef patty topped with BBQ sauce, bacon, cheddar cheese, and haystack onion rings.

Sourdough Mushroom Swiss Burger $9.99
A seasoned beef patty topped with sauteed mushrooms and melted Swiss cheese on grilled sourdough bread.

Reuben Cheeseburger $10.59
A 1/2 lb. fresh ground beef patty topped with corned beef and Swiss cheese.

Grilled Cheese Sandwich $6.99
Your choice of bread grilled to perfection with cheese.

For kids 10 and under.
Served with a small beverage and french fries

Grilled Cheese
Cheese Pizza
Chicken Tenders
Mac & Cheese

Malts & Shakes  $3.99
Chocolate, Vanilla or Strawberry

Feature Flavor Cheesecake  $5.49
Turtle Cheesecake  $5.99

Ice Cream Sundae  $2.99
Hot Fudge or Strawberry


Served only on Fridays with homemade cole slaw, choice of potato and rye bread.

Fresh Lake Perch  $14.99

* Baked Stuffed Cod Hollandaise  $12.99
Stuffed with Nisleit’s homemade crabmeat stuffing

Fried Cod  $11.49

Broiled Cod  $11.99

All You Can Eat Alaskan Pollack $8.95

NOTICE:  Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have a medical condition.

* Look for our favorites!

Prices and items subject to change without notice.